Second Circuit Revives the Suit Against New York City's Handgun Rules
Source: The Daily Caller (Nov 2026)

Image: Kidfly182 / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)
A federal appeals court resurrected a lawsuit against New York City on Tuesday over its handgun rules, The Daily Caller reports. A panel of Senior Circuit Judges Reena Raggi and Debra Ann Livingston and Circuit Judge Michael H. Park held that three provisions should not have been thrown out at the first step of the Bruen analysis.
The three rules: a limit of one handgun carried at any one time, a mandatory 90-day wait between handgun purchases, and a cap of two handguns registered on a carry licence.
Writing for the panel, Raggi said each of the activities at issue falls within the ordinary meaning of the right to keep and bear arms, and that the district court should have asked that question before dismissing. The opinion notes the 90-day delay operates to constrain the right rather than to regulate its exercise in some lesser way.
District Judge Jed S. Rakoff had dismissed the case with prejudice in December 2024, reasoning that because the city's limits were not a permanent ban, the Second Amendment was not implicated. The panel vacated that judgment and remanded for further consideration.
Nothing here is a ruling on the merits: the rules are back before a district court, not struck down. But it puts three of New York City's carry-era restrictions back in play at a time when the Second Circuit has been taking a harder look at exactly this kind of licensing architecture.
Via The Daily Caller, November 12, 2026.
Get this every Thursday. The week in guns, booze and tobacco, in one quick read.
Comments
No comments yet - be the first to post one.
The Week In Guns, Booze & Tobacco. In One Quick Read.
The stories that actually mattered, from ATF moves to industry money to what everyone's talking about. Every Thursday. No junk.
Unsubscribing is one click β the link is in every edition.
We store your address to send the newsletter and nothing else.