FreedomWireFreedom Through Alcohol, Tobacco & Firearms
← Back to feed
FirearmsNews

Fifth Circuit Won't Take the Machine-Gun Ban Challenge En Banc — 9–8 Against

TacticalRegulation
Share𝕏 Postf Share

Source: The Firearm Blog (Nov 2026)

Fifth Circuit Won't Take the Machine-Gun Ban Challenge En Banc — 9–8 Against

Image: The Firearm Blog

On November 4 the Fifth Circuit voted 9–8 against hearing the Temple Gun Club's challenge initially en banc, which means it goes through a normal three-judge panel first. The club needed nine of the court's 17 active judges to force the full bench. It got eight.

The Temple Gun Club is a Texas nonprofit with more than 1,000 members. It sued on March 10 in federal court in Fort Worth with members Jeffrey Howard, Clark Miracle and Jason Armstrong as plaintiffs, naming the U.S. attorney general and ATF officials as defendants.

The target is 18 U.S.C. § 922(o), the Hughes Amendment, which bans the transfer or possession of machine guns made after May 19, 1986, with exceptions for government use and pre-ban guns. This is not a Second Amendment case: the club argues that Congress never had Commerce Clause power to ban mere possession, especially of a gun made and kept inside one state. DOJ's answer was that every circuit to consider the question, the Fifth included, has upheld the ban.

Judge Andrew S. Oldham dissented, joined by Judge James C. Ho. "As far as I am aware, there is no historical justification for banning machine guns," he wrote. He tied the question to United States v. Squire, a Louisiana felon-in-possession case the full court agreed on July 20 to rehear on whether the Commerce Clause supports § 922(g)(1) — noting that § 922(g) has a built-in interstate-commerce hook and § 922(o) does not. Squire is on the Fifth Circuit's January 2027 en banc calendar, and DOJ told the court a panel could then weigh whether its reasoning applies here.

Until then a panel is bound by existing circuit precedent, which the opinion refers to as Knutson. If the club ultimately won, its members could make or buy post-1986 machine guns — still with NFA registration and the $200 tax.

Get this every Thursday. The week in guns, booze and tobacco, in one quick read.

Comments

No comments yet - be the first to post one.

    All Firearms

    The Week In Guns, Booze & Tobacco. In One Quick Read.

    The stories that actually mattered, from ATF moves to industry money to what everyone's talking about. Every Thursday. No junk.

    Unsubscribing is one click — the link is in every edition.

    We store your address to send the newsletter and nothing else.